How to vet a custom apparel manufacturer
By UniformsOS Team. Updated .
Start with fit, not price
Factories specialize. A cut-and-sew house that sublimates teamwear all day is not a screen printer, and a screen printer is not an embroidery shop. The cheapest quote from a factory that does not normally make your product is the most expensive order you will place.
Ask what it made last month. Ask for photos of current production, not a catalog. Then ask which steps happen under its own roof. Printing, sewing, embroidery and packing are often split between companies, and every handoff is a place for delay and blame.
The questions to ask
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| What is your minimum, and is it per order, per style or per color? | The same number means very different commitments |
| What is your lead time for a sample and for bulk, now and in peak season? | Quoted lead times are for a quiet month |
| Which steps do you subcontract? | You need to know who is really making it |
| Who buys the fabric, and what do you stock? | Stocked fabric means lower minimums and faster starts |
| How do you check quality during production and before shipping? | You want checks on the line, not only at the end |
| What happens when pieces are defective or the order is late? | Remake, credit or refund should be agreed before there is a problem |
| What are your payment terms? | Deposits of 30 to 50 percent with the balance before shipping are common for new customers |
| Who is my contact, and how fast do you answer? | One named person. Slow answers before the order get slower after it |
| What shipping terms do you quote? | EXW, FOB and DDP put very different costs on you |
On shipping terms: these are Incoterms, published by the International Chamber of Commerce. Under EXW you collect the goods at the factory door and pay for everything after it. Under FOB the factory gets them onto the ship at its port. Under DDP the factory delivers to your door with duties paid. Compare quotes only on the same term.
Pay for a sample
Send your tech pack and pay for a sample made to it. A free sample pulled from the showroom tells you what the factory can make on its best day for someone else.
Check four things when it arrives:
- Measurements. Measure every point on your spec sheet and compare against your tolerances.
- Color. Compare against your reference in daylight.
- Construction. Look at the seams inside and out, the stitch type and density, the thread ends and the label placement.
- Washing. Wash and dry it five times the way a parent would. Then check for shrinkage, color bleed, cracked prints and popped seams.
Before bulk production, approve a pre-production sample made on the real production line with the real fabric. Keep one signed copy and have the factory keep another. That sample is the standard the order is judged against.
Check references and audits
Ask for two customers who buy the same type of product, and call them. Ask what went wrong and how the factory handled it. Every factory has had a bad order. You are finding out what it did next.
Ask for the latest audit report, not only a certificate. Check the date and the address on it. The common ones:
| Audit or standard | What it covers |
|---|---|
| WRAP, amfori BSCI, SMETA, SA8000 | Labor conditions and workplace safety |
| ISO 9001 | Whether the factory runs a quality management system |
| OEKO-TEX Standard 100 | Testing of textiles for harmful substances |
A certificate does not guarantee a good order. A factory that refuses to show any report is telling you something.
If the volume justifies it, visit. If it does not, ask for a live video walk through the floor, and consider paying a third-party inspection company for a day.
Place a small first order
Make the first order small enough to lose. Put it on a written purchase order with:
- the approved sample and tech pack it must match
- quantities by size
- the price and the payment schedule
- the ship date
- the quality standard and how it will be checked
- what happens if it is late or wrong
For the quality standard, most apparel buyers use AQL sampling. AQL stands for acceptance quality limit. An inspector pulls a set number of pieces from the finished order, based on the sampling tables in ISO 2859-1, and the order passes or fails on the number of defects found. AQL 2.5 for major defects and 4.0 for minor ones is the usual starting point for apparel.
Inspect before you pay the balance. For a large order, send an inspector. For a small one, ask for photos of the packed order, a count by size and measurements of a few pieces on video.
Red flags
- It says yes to everything. Real factories have limits and tell you what they are.
- The lowest price, the fastest lead time and no minimum, all at once.
- It will not say what is subcontracted.
- The sample is perfect and it cannot tell you which line will make the bulk.
- It wants full payment up front on a first order.
- It cannot name a customer who buys your type of product.
Keep score after the first order
Vetting does not end with the first shipment. Track four numbers for every factory:
| Measure | How to calculate it |
|---|---|
| On-time rate | Orders shipped on or before the agreed date, divided by orders shipped |
| Defect rate | Pieces rejected, divided by pieces received |
| Remake rate | Orders that needed a remake, divided by orders |
| Response time | How long a question waits for an answer |
Three orders tell you more than any audit. And keep a second factory qualified for each core product. One late run should not stop your season.
Tracking a factory after you choose it
In UniformsOS each factory gets its own purchase orders and its own login, where it accepts the job, uploads test prints and reports the stage. Every purchase order is marked on time, due soon or late against its ship-by date, and reports count late purchase orders by factory. See Manufacturers and Vendors and UniformsOS for factories.
FAQ
- How many factories should I work with?
- At least two for each core product. A second source protects you when one is late or full.
- What deposit is normal for a first order?
- Commonly 30 to 50 percent with the order and the balance before shipping. Better terms come with history.
- What is AQL in apparel?
- Acceptance quality limit. It is a sampling method for inspecting a finished order. A set number of pieces are checked, and the order passes or fails on the defects found.
- Should I visit the factory?
- If the volume justifies the trip, yes. Otherwise use a live video walk through the floor and a third-party inspection.
- Is a domestic factory better than an overseas one?
- It depends on the order. Domestic production is usually faster with smaller minimums and a higher price per piece. Overseas production costs less at volume and adds transit time, duties and distance.
Sources
- ISO 2859-1, Sampling procedures for inspection by attributes. Part 1: Sampling schemes indexed by acceptance quality limit (AQL) for lot-by-lot inspection, International Organization for Standardization
- Incoterms rules, International Chamber of Commerce
Related articles
- Managing apparel factories and purchase ordersHow to run day-to-day work with apparel factories: what a purchase order must contain, splitting orders, confirmations, status updates, changes and receiving.
- Tech pack checklist: the ten parts a factory needsA checklist of the ten parts of an apparel tech pack, what each must contain, the gaps factories complain about most and how to test yours before sending it.
- Custom apparel production stages: from approved order to shipped boxThe stages a custom apparel order goes through in production, what happens at each one, what goes wrong and the check that catches it.
See UniformsOS on a live workspace
Thirty minutes on Google Meet with someone who has run a production floor on this system.
